Chelsea Definitely Need Experience - But There's a Line Between 'Experienced' and 'Old'

Chelsea Definitely Need Experience - But There's a Line Between 'Experienced' and 'Old'

Premier League Blog

Chelsea’s Average Age Has to Come Up, But How Much is Too Much?

It has been clear ever since Behdad Egbhali and Todd Boehly took ownership of Chelsea Football Club that the average age was going to be a problem. Almost exclusively signing under 25 prospects, and selling anyone with a modicum of experience, it wasn’t long until the Blues boasted what was effectively a squad of young, petulant children, hence their woeful discpline record of 10 red card in all comps last season.

Employing head coaches rather than managers in the four years since the Blue Co. takeover, managers have had no say in the clubs transfer business, with this instead left up to the now vigorously hated sporting directors Paul Winstanley, Joe Shields and Laurence Stewart.

With Xabi Alonso hired in the summer under the title of ‘manager’, it seems the owners have finally realised the errors of their ways. The signing of Maxence Lacroix represented the first time chelsea had spent money on a player aged 26 or over since Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang four years ago, or more than 40 signings ago. A truly mental stat.

However, Alonso hasn't stopped there, letting the board know exactly how much experience they have been lacking, as in the last 24 hours, the Spaniard has taken in interest in 35-year-old Danny Welbeck and 36-year-old Jordan Henderson.

These player’s would be excellent individuals to bring in to help bring some maturity to the ranks, but are they experienced, or are they just old?

Savvy or Stupid?

The dual interest in Henderson and Welbeck comes just weeks after the Blues showed interest in another OAP in John Stones, who now appears to be Inter Milan-bound.

It is clear what Alonso’s strategy is this summer: bring know-how and nous, and let it rub off on the extremely young squad that sorely need an example to follow. Jordan Henderson is a prime example of someone who can teach them a thing or two - at 36, and boasting 463 Premier League appearances, he is the definition of a midfield leader, someone who has been there and done that.

Welbeck is a close second; the former Man United, Arsenal, and Sunderland man has 400 league games to his name, accompanied by an impressive tally of 92 Premier League goals (seven of which have come against Chelsea).

There is certainly an argument that the ploy could work. After all, Henderson helped Brentford just goal difference away from their first ever qualification for Europe, falling at the final hurdle against former club Liverpool. He played 34 times, scored once, assisted three, and was a crucial part of the side, showing all of the winning experience and elite mentality he had picked up in his 12 years at Liverpool.

Welbeck has likewise got plenty of positives, the most obvious being that last season was the best goalscoring season of his career, as the Englishman netted 14 across all competitions. Brighton’s top PL goalscorer for two seasons running, he has shown himself to be something of a fine wine: he is ageing well.

Chelsea’s interest may also stem from a desire to simply stop him scoring against them - he netted against the West London side in both Premier League last season, and has been a near constant thorn in the side of the Blues since moving to Brighton, whether the fixture be in the league, cup, or simply a friendly.

Henderson and Welbeck boast a combined total of 34 years of Premier League experience, a depth of knowledge very few have the privilege of acquiring, and a quantity that most coaches would kill to have in their team.

But to sign both of them in tandem? That seems to be overdoing it.

A Young Man’s Game

Henderson’s age was highlighted for all to see this summer, as he was taken to the World Cup by Thomas Tuchel and played just six minutes in what was effectively a dead rubber group game against Panama.

Of course, wasn’t helped by the fact that he broke his arm during a run-in with the advertising hoardings in the wake of England’s victory over Mexico, but realistically, he was always there more for squad morale than squad depth.

It begs the question: will he fulfil the same role at Chelsea? Will his job be to go around the dressing room imparting knowledge to his new teammates rather than play alongside them on the field? In certain ways, that can be very helpful, but you can never gain more from a player than when you are able to witness first hand what their experience gives them on the pitch.

At one year younger, Welbeck is a slightly more feasible option, but only marginally - in reality, he probably has one, or perhaps two good Premier League seasons left, and although he certainly boasts top flight quality, that doesn’t necessarily equate to top team quality.

He is very much an upper mid-table striker, capable of being a reliable but unspectacular presence up top without doing anything flashy or outrageous, and certainly not lethal enough to earn a move to a side pushing for Champions League football.

Stones would have been the ideal experience option for Chelsea - at 32, he is significantly younger than both Henderson and Welbeck, and having played considerable minutes for England at the World Cup, while also helping Manchester City to two major trophies last season, it is clear he is still operating very close to his top level.

Unfortunately, Chelsea look to be too late to secure his signature, with Inter Milan instead swopping in to sweep up the Englishman, and it leaves the Blues with a rather older demographic of experienced players than they would like.

Either Welbeck or Henderson should be brought to the club - they provide a steady presence, a well of knowledge, and an instinct that pays off more often than not thanks to the sheer number of years they have been doing what they do at the highest level.

But bringing in both of them? Nah. 1. They would barely play, and would be a drain on the wage budget, and 2. If they become unhappy with that, their unhappiness will spread far and wide because of their predicted influence on the dressing room.

Welbeck as a backup to Pedro is fine, Henderson as an emergency fill-in for the injury-prone Romeo Lavia is just about ok, but to bring in both is to waste the time of all involved. At the end of the day, Welbeck and Henderson are old in football terms, and to have too many old players around is to forgo the best competitive level the team can be.

Harry Pascoe
Lead Writer

Harry Pascoe - Lead Content Writer

Harry is an NCTJ-certified journalist and the longest-serving writer at Football Park. With a career that includes contributions to Goal.com and the Mail on Sunday, he has built a strong reputation for thoughtful analysis, sharp reporting, and an authentic passion for the game.

A lifelong Chelsea fan, Harry combines a deep understanding of the sport with an appreciation for its emotional heartbeat — from the glamour of the Premier League and the intensity of international tournaments to the gritty community spirit of non-league football.

Over the years, Harry has covered tactical deep dives, player interviews, and opinion pieces that resonate with readers across all levels of the football pyramid. Whether reporting from the stands or writing from the office, Harry brings a unique voice that captures the essence of the world’s most loved sport.

Harry Pascoe on LinkedIn

View all articles by Harry Pascoe →