Has Kobbie Mainoo Been Forgotten by Tuchel or is he Just Hugely Overrated?
World Cup Blog
Has Kobbie Mainoo Been Forgotten by Tuchel or is he Just Hugely Overrated?
Kobbie Mainoo’s situation is a unique one. Clamoured for two years ago at the 2024 European Championships, he became something of a cult hero for his coolness and composure in the heart of the English midfield as Gareth Southgate’s men fell just one hurdle short of a major trophy.
Now though, with England in the 2026 World Cup semi-finals in the new era of Thomas Tuchel, Mainoo remains as one of just three outfielders in the squad to have not played a single minute of tournament football, along with Ivan Toney and Trevoh Chalobah.
World Cup 2026: Why has #England midfielder Kobbie Mainoo failed to play a single minute for Thomas Tuchel's side this summer? #mufc https://t.co/Pn00LaN0mx
— Rob Dorsett (@RobDorsettSky) July 14, 2026
Mainoo occupies an equally confusing role at parent club Manchester United: fans beg him to be in the starting eleven, but in truth, he never plays anywhere near the amount he should.
It begs the question: is Kobbie Mainoo actually as good as everybody says he is, or is it a classic case of English media bias?
Main-oo Event or Side Character?
Everyone remembers where they were when an 18-year-old Mainoo burst onto the Premier League scene with a stunning 97th-minute winner against Wolves back in 2024. Confident, fearless, creative and mature, he looked like the real deal, the complete package that had the ability to lockdown the England midfield for a generation.
Kobbie Mainoo was a key part of England’s Euro 2024 squad. Featured in all but one game during the run to the final and looked like he would be the future of England’s midfield. 🏴💔
— Rising Ballers (@RisingBallers_) July 14, 2026
Fast-forward two years and it’s zero minutes for Kobbie at the 2026 World Cup. There’s defo a… pic.twitter.com/j35KbrZZBe
Many tipped him for a big move, and Chelsea showed interest in the midfielder for well over a year only for nothing to materialise. But while everyone was still neck deep in praise for the youngster for his, others started to notice that he wasn’t being used as much as a player of his assumed quality should be.
He is yet to feature in 40+ games in a season for Man United while most of his teammates are featuring in 50+, and his numbers of 1 goal and 3 assists across the 2025/26 season were below par, considering he netted five in his maiden season.
Granted, his primary strength is not in front of goal – his main role is to dictate the tempo of the game and to pose as a valuable blockade in the centre of midfield, breaking up any opposing attacks. However, he showed in 2024 that he had a potent attacking side to his game, and the fact that it hasn’t been used to full effect seems like a colossal waste of potential.
Tuchel obviously has a unique insight into the players in his team and is clearly seeing something the rest of us aren't – he played Mainoo in both pre-tournament friendlies against New Zealand and Costa Rica, and according to FotMob, Mainoo was impressive in each, scoring ratings of 7.1 and 7.0, respectively.
However, clearly there is something about his game, his temperament or his nature that Tuchel believes is not suitable for World Cup football, and fairly or unfairly, he has refused to play the high-rated Red Devils youngster.
Mentality Issue?
Let’s be clear here; we don’t think Mainoo is overrated – his pivotal role in England’s 2024 Euro campaign, as well as his consistent stream of outrageous technical moments for his club, means that anyone arguing that he isn’t good enough clearly doesn’t watch enough football.
The most likely reason? A matter of mentality – does Mainoo have what it takes mentally to consistently play at the top of his game and deal with the pressure of playing at an elite level week in and week out? Does he have the strength of character to stomach being left out?
Look at this picture and tell me you don’t see a problem and I’d tell you.
— GiddyFx (@giddy_fx) July 12, 2026
Everyone here is keeping faces like they don’t have a problem except one little Mr carrington Zidane.
Ivan Toney, who’s a more important player to England than Kobbie Mainoo, hasn’t started any games… pic.twitter.com/Q2gAPlMR94
According to Sky News reporter Rob Dorsett, who has been on sight with the England squad for the entire World Cup, Mainoo has been the first to leave the team dressing room after every single game. After the Norway game in particular, he didn’t look best pleased – while his countrymen were fist-bumping journalists and celebrating a huge win, Mainoo walked stony-faced through the throng, unwilling to share or give away any flicker of emotion.
Similarly, in the scenes of post-match celebration when the England players and fans sing Wonderwall in unison, Mainoo stands as the only face clearly not enjoying himself – he is clearly busy wondering why he was called up to do bugger all. He looked as if his dog had been kidnapped right after England had booked a ticket to the World Cup semi-final – no need for the long face really, is there?
As Dorsett describes it, the Man United talent looks lost.
When Jordan Henderson, Tuchel’s go-to midfield bench option, broke his wrist in the wake of England’s famous win over Mexico at the Azteca, it was assumed that Mainoo would slot into the role of impact sub, the sort of player who would be subbed on with 15 minutes left, providing fresh legs in the finishing stages as well as extra time, as is what happened in the Norway game.
Instead, Tuchel brought on Morgan Rogers and Ebere Eze as his midfield reinforcements, with Reece James, Dan Burn, Bukayo Saka and Djed Spence the other four substitutions. No Kobbie Mainoo, despite the fact that his unique control and composed style would have brought England a modicum of security in what was a truly topsy-turvy clash.
The surprise was multiplied by the fact that Declan Rice, who, alongside Elliot Anderson, has nailed down the deeper role in the England midfield, was hooked after 45 minutes, having only made a partial recovery from the Mexican stomach bug that had left him bedridden for three days.
His natural replacement was Mainoo; very few will debate that, but clearly, Tuchel saw things differently. Reece James came on for him, and then when Konsa was forced off with cramp, Morgan Rogers took the spot in midfield and played a more advanced role, with James shifting into a more familiar defensive role.
There is clearly something about Mainoo that Tuchel and his coaching staff don’t like about Mainoo, and it’s clear it is not his technical ability.
Perhaps it is a lack of ability to perform in the hot, sticky, energy-sapping conditions that have plagued the Three Lions throughout their time in America, or perhaps it is an issue of a 21-year-old failing to bring the desired mindset that would make him a valued part of the squad.
Either way, unless England are dumped out against Argentina and forced to play the charity match that is the 3rd/4th place play-off, Mainoo looks supremely unlikely to play a role in this World Cup, and that is a shame. Having seen him at his best, we know exactly what we are missing. We just hope he has the strength to come through this period, where things are at their worst.
Louis Wheeldon
Oliver Seymour