Is the 2026/27 Premier League Season Nothing More Than a Farce? That’s How It Felt After City Destroyed Liverpool…
Premier League Blog
Proven Guilty and Still Winning - What Do We Do If Man City Keep Winning Games?
It’s utterly bonkers. Mad. Straight-up wrong. Just two weeks after Manchester City were proven guilty on all but one of the 115 charges of financial misconduct, failing to comply with investigators and a handful of other scandalous activities, their decisive 3-0 win over Liverpool at Anfield ensured they maintained their 100% winning start to the season, moving five points clear of Arsenal in the process.
We know that the table is wrong - with City’s inevitable hefty punishment incoming, likely in the form of a hefty points deduction of expulsion from the league, they are simply a placeholder at the top of the league until that punishment is finalised.
But what is the point in going ahead with the campaign if a side that in a few months' time won’t be in the league anymore keeps winning points that will end up being pointless? What difference could those points have made to the other side's campaign if City had been punished immediately after the guilty verdict?
The season just feels a little bit pointless right now…
Suspended Sentence
It seems that for now, at least, Man City have been given a stay of execution, the fact that the club lodged an appeal during the international break enough to ensure that, at the very least, they secure another month or so in the Premier League.
But eventually, the truth will out – it always does, and when City have no other way to postpone their sentence, the Premier League must be ready with a proportionately severe punishment.
The issue is that, despite the huge amount of discourse surrounding the matter, no one in the Premier League chambers of power seems to have an answer – nothing has been leaked, nothing has been suggested, and in fact, we haven’t heard a pipsqueak out of the English top-flight governing body.
If Manchester City win every game this season, how many points will they finish with?
You guessed it. 114. https://t.co/fngNMigC4i
— Football Tweet ⚽ (@Footballtweet) October 11, 2026
Naturally, in an unprecedented situation such as this, the Premier League does not have a ready-made punishment waiting in the wings to dish out, and deliberation on how best to move forward can take some time.
But it is also clear that City’s presence in the top flight, and their absolute domination of it so far this season, is quickly rendering the campaign null and void – it will simply be another title lift tainted by City’s financial misgivings committed between 2009 and 2018, without which they would not be the team they are today.
The city needs punishment ASAP, as their presence in the league will only become more telling as the season goes on – if they draw out the legal process long enough, they may irreparably influence which way the title goes in a season which they are supposedly meant to have absolutely no sway in.
Red Card Controversy
The meeting with Liverpool itself was thrilling for around an hour. Neither side had brought their finishing boots, but the shots kept coming, the tackles kept flying, and the tempo remained pulsating high.
However, it was all ruined by referee Chris Kavangh, who in the 62nd minute showed Ryan Gravenberch a second yellow card, condemning him to an early shower and an evening of self-pity.
It was so soft. The first yellow card came from making almost no contact at all with Elliot Anderson, who certainly milked the damage the Dutchman had done to him, and the second, while perhaps more deserving, barely warranted punishment from the referee – Jeremy Doku, who was brought to ground, even tried to get up and continue play, a telling indicator that the challenge, while a foul, deserved nothing more.
Fans were quick to point out online that Kavangh was in fact born in Manchester back in 1985 and accused him of bias towards the guilty visiting side.
🚨JUST IN: Micah Richards: “The two yellow cards for Gravenberch WERE SOFT”
Chris Kavanagh, today's referee was born in Manchester. Kavanagh was the VAR official during the INFAMOUS Rodri handball incident in Everton 0–1 Manchester City in 2022. https://t.co/dOaPhNcNHR
— Polymarket FC (@PolymarketFC) October 11, 2026
While building on that point would lead down the winding path that ends in ‘conspiracy theory’, it certainly once again dredged up the most talked about topic in English football - VAR. Should VAR have been allowed to intervene with the second yellow card? Why shouldn’t there be a system where a yellow card is rescinded if it is deemed not worthy by the team in the VAR room, which Gravenberch’s first card certainly was?
Regardless of the systems that we don't have in place, the sending off ruined a fascinating game, and robbed the entire country of an opportunity to see Man City lose immediately in the wake of being exposed for fraud - truly a moment squandered by woeful refereeing.
Sinking City
We have seen a lot of the same long-running issues resurface throughout the season already, while City’s impending sentence hangs over the league like a dark cloud.
The scenes of celebration in the away end and on the pitch as City scored three fabulous goals in 13 minutes were jubilant - you wouldn’t have known that the possibility of being expelled from the Premier League was in the back of everyone’s minds.
But what was the point in celebrating? In the long run, the win over Liverpool won’t matter a jot, so as fans, why bother showing up at all? And the same applies to the players – with mind-boggling repercussions on their way, the club only has a short while left in the Premier League, so why were they all looking so pleased?
Why are Man City players celebrating?
Can’t wait to see their face when they will sit 20th in the table after a points deduction. https://t.co/coJhtUHGEN
— Ocho (@Ocho_CFC) October 11, 2026
I understand that the win was a response to all of the headlines that came out over the international break and that the players and fans wanted to remind everyone what they could do on the pitch instead of off it.
I also get that, with punishments incoming, fans and players alike are enjoying their time in the Premier League as if it is some sort of free trial, something which one day, with no warning, will be unceremoniously torn away from them. So naturally there were going to be scenes of jubilant, even defiant, celebration.
But everyone knows what is coming – all the Premier League needs to do is coordinate with the EFL and National League to ensure that City don’t see the Premier League light of day for decades, a punishment fitting of their crimes, and with that hanging over the club, the league and the country, the Premier League cannot be taken at all seriously as of right now.
In addition, every time City play a league, they are affecting the final league table in a way in which they are certainly not entitled to - their punishment will be confirmed before the end of the season, meaning that they themselves cannot win the title, but they can certainly impact who does end up lifting the trophy, who gets relegated, and who qualifies for Europe.
Until City are sent down to the footballing equivalent of Davy Jones’s locker, we will not be able to take the English top flight seriously. For once, it is everyone else in Europe calling it a farce, not the other way around.
Louis Wheeldon