League Cup Draw RIGGED? Analysing Man City's Cup Ties as Fans Call for 116th Charge
Football Blog
"Make it 116 Charges!" - Analysing Manchester City's League Cup Draw History
Well fans are calling for another charge to be added onto the bill for Manchester City after being stunned by how easy their League Cup draws have been in recent history.
This follows them landing Bradford City in the next round of the competition after dumping out Brighton on penalties on Wednesday evening.
But this does beg the question, is this actually a justified shout? Have Manchester City really been that lucky in the League Cup over the past few years and so much so they might have rigged it?
Here at Football Park we're going to be analysing the last 5 years of Manchester City's draws to help finally put to bed whether the 116th charge needs to be added for rigging the draws.
The #CarabaoCup Quarter-Final draw has now been confirmed. 🏆
EFL https://t.co/9WByuvbNbI— Carabao Cup (@Carabao_Cup) October 28, 2026
26/27 Season:
September 17th - Norwich City (H) October 28th - Brighton (H) December 15th - Bradford City (H)
So obviously only a few draws have taken place so far in the 26/27 League Cup however it has already fallen very much in the favour of City.
Not only have they managed to draw 2 Championship sides but every single game has been a home draw which as we know has a huge influence over the outcome of a football match
25/26 Season:
September 24 - Huddersfield Town (A) October 29 - Swansea City (A) December 17th - Brentford (H) January 13th - Newcastle United (A) February 4th - Newcastle United (H) March 22nd - Arsenal (Neutral)
What stands out about City's 25/26 League Cup winning campaign immediately is that they had a very easy start in the early rounds playing 2 lower league sides although both were played away from hime so we can't pick this out as in their favour.
Speaking of in their favour however we can see that the quarter and semi-finals were played at home at the most beneficial time for City.
In the Brentford single legged game they played at home and in the semis they were fortunate enough to have the home leg second which is hugely advantageous in knockout football.
24/25 Season:
September 24th - Watford (H) October 30th - Tottenham Hotspur (A)
So off the bat we can see that this was an early exit campaign in the League Cup for City but interestingly this stands out due to the fact that at the first tough away fixture in the draw so far is where they were knocked out of the competition.
Watford at home as an opener into the competition is what we would consider a relatively easy game for City however this is a fairly routine draw for big sides at this stage of the competition but the loss to Spurs sticks out for 'falling at the first difficult hurdle'.
23/24 Season:
September 27th - Newcastle United (A)
The year before being dumped out at Spurs away actually had a more embarassingly early exit from the competition for City as they were knocked out in the opening fixture by Newcastle United.
For the purposes of the analysing their draw luck though this is evidently not an easy draw however it is also noteworthy that this makes back to back examples of tough draws equating to early exists for City so maybe we need to wonder if they're on fraud watch?
22/23 Season:
November 9th - Chelsea (H) December 22nd - Liverpool (H) January 11th - Southampton (A)
The 22/23 season was perhaps the toughest draw that City has ever faced in the League Cup and was very clearly unlucky to draw both Chelsea and Liverpool in the opening rounds, the only thing that is lucky is that they maaged to draw both at home but considering you usually expect Championship teams at these stages it would be fair to say there was anything lucky about these two.
Ironically City managed to beat both Chelsea and Liverpool but proceeded to be beat 2-0 by Southampton to be dumped out of the cup, you could argue that Southampton at the latter stages of the Cup is fairly lucky but evidently they were there due to playing briliantly.
Conclusion:
Well from looking at the last 5 seasons worth of draws its fair to say the City have had the rub of the green more often than not be it directly through their fixtures or simply through the majority of tough draws falling into their favour with the benfit of playing at home.
However if anyone sat at home reading this genuinely believes that the League Cup draw is rigged in favour of City all I can say is that you need to give your head a wobble.
They have had luck but nowhere near enough to be thinking that it's rigged in their favour, take the 23/24 and 24/25 seasons for example, playing away to very tough Premier League opposition during the two earliest stages of the competition is rotten luck.
Ultimately saying City are luckier in the draws than most other clubs is fair to say, the evidence is right in front of our faces that this is the case but it's nowhere near a level of rigging, and trust me this is coming from an Arsenal fan so it pains me to defend them.
If City manage to go through the next few League Cup draws with incredible luck then I will maybe start to understand the crowd that believe they're rigging it better however right now that is simply not the case even if they have had a lot fall in their favour.
A record crowd for a domestic cup tie at the Etihad tonight 🏡🩵
Thanks for your top support as always, Blues. Onto Saturday 💪 https://t.co/4vh9W4pAbS
— Manchester City (@ManCity) October 28, 2026
Louis Wheeldon