Everton 3-1 Newcastle United: Match Report and Player Ratings

Everton 3-1 Newcastle United: Match Report and Player Ratings

Match Previews/Reviews

A Cup Run? Surely not…

Everton finally rediscovered their shooting boots after two weeks of searching as the Toffees booked their place in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals. But was the performance worthy of the scoreline?

I do love jinxing us. In a good way, for once?

Just days after I wrote an article explaining why Everton were in serious trouble, David Moyes and his players decided to make me look like a complete idiot, not for the first time.

Three goals, a victory over Premier League opposition and a place in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals. Bloody hell, we might actually be getting somewhere!

Despite already looking at London hotel prices for next year's final, I think Everton supporters and players alike should probably avoid getting too carried away.

Newcastle were shite. Hardly surprising given their wildly inconsistent start to the season, but even by their standards, this was a particularly uninspiring showing.

Not to take anything away from Everton's three goals, all of which were taken exceptionally well. However, the 3-1 scoreline arguably flattered the Toffees, who were far from convincing despite securing a desperately needed victory.

Goals from James Garner, Hayden Hackney and Thierno Barry ensured Everton progressed to the last eight, where League Two side Fleetwood Town await, and after a dismal two weeks in terms of results and performance, this was much needed.

I don't know what's more surprising: the fact that League One and League Two clubs have made the quarter-finals, or that Everton have joined them.

A Shaky Start, But Garner Delivers

Moyes made two changes from the side beaten by Arsenal, with Hackney and Tyler Dibling replacing Harrison Armstrong and Brennan Johnson.

Jack Grealish was also absent from the squad following a breach of club discipline, a decision that raised plenty of eyebrows before a ball had even been kicked.

The opening exchanges were hardly the most convincing from an Everton perspective.

Newcastle enjoyed their fair share of possession and looked particularly threatening down their left flank, where Harvey Barnes repeatedly caused problems for Merlin Röhl.

The German, deployed at right-back (again…), looked distinctly uncomfortable throughout the evening. Had Barnes been more clinical with his opportunities, Everton could easily have found themselves chasing the game.

A tame header from Barnes six yards from goal saw Jordan Pickford called into action, as the Mackem upset the travelling 7,000 Geordies for not the first time that evening.

For all Newcastle's attacking promise, however, their finishing left plenty to be desired, and in the 34th minute, Everton made them pay.

Tyrique George pressured Amar Dedić into surrendering possession near the Newcastle penalty area, allowing Hackney to intelligently lay the ball into the path of Garner.

The midfielder needed no second invitation, curling a beautiful effort into the bottom corner to give Everton the lead.

A fantastic finish, and precisely the sort of quality we've been crying out for in recent weeks. Mad what happens when you try and score goals isn’t it?

Hackney Makes His Mark

With half-time approaching, Newcastle squandered another attacking opportunity, allowing Pickford to initiate a swift counterattack.

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall carried the ball forward before being brought down, but the referee allowed play to continue as Barry advanced down the right.

The Frenchman delivered an excellent cross into the penalty area, where Hackney arrived to guide a first-time finish into the bottom corner.

A first goal in Royal Blue for a player who has spent far too much time watching from the sidelines, a special moment for him.

I've been calling for Hackney to receive more opportunities for weeks, and performances like this demonstrate exactly why.

An assist for Garner's opener, a brilliantly taken goal of his own and a genuine willingness to drive Everton forward.

What more does he need to do to earn a regular starting place?

Dibling and George, meanwhile, were rather less convincing.

Neither was particularly poor, but neither exactly seized the opportunity to make themselves undroppable, either.

Still, I would much rather see these players given meaningful minutes than expect them to transform Everton's fortunes from the substitutes' bench every week.

Barry Puts the Game Beyond Doubt

Newcastle applied more pressure after the break, enjoying plenty of possession as Everton sat back. Unfortunately for the visitors, nothing seemed to click. A familiar standard of attacking football at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, admittedly.

That gave Everton the chance to put the tie to bed, an opportunity Barry duly took.

In the 69th minute, Garner helped launch another counterattack, finding Dewsbury-Hall advancing down the left.

The midfielder, who looked far more like his usual self throughout the evening, picked out Barry inside the penalty area.

He took one touch to control, and another to side-foot it past Lukáš Horníček to see the game beyond doubt.

Despite the striker's ongoing issues in front of goal, he's still come on leaps and bounds this season, and he took his opportunity exceptionally well on Thursday night. A goal and an assist is nothing to sniff at either.

With the tie effectively settled, Newcastle continued to push forward and eventually found a consolation through Dan Burn, whose late header denied Everton a clean sheet.

There was also a rather unnecessary confrontation in the closing stages, with several players receiving bookings as tempers flared (and a lovely moment of James Tarkowski dragging Joelinton to the floor like a ragdoll).

Nevertheless, Everton held firm to secure their passage into the quarter-finals.

Man of the Match — Hayden Hackney

For all the positives surrounding Dewsbury-Hall's return to form, there's only one winner for me.

Hackney was excellent going forward, providing the assist for Garner's opener before scoring his first Everton goal with a superbly timed run into the penalty area.

More importantly, he offered the sort of attacking ambition and movement that Everton's midfield has desperately lacked in recent weeks.

I've been advocating for the former Middlesbrough midfielder to start more regularly, and he certainly hasn't done anything to change my mind.

If anything, he's made Moyes' next team selection considerably more difficult, which is exactly what we need.

Bad Day — Merlin Röhl

Playing out of position at right-back certainly didn't do Röhl any favours, but this was a particularly uncomfortable evening for the German. Harvey Barnes repeatedly exploited the space around him, with Röhl making several mistakes that a more clinical Newcastle side could easily have punished.

Had the visitors taken their opportunities, we might have been discussing a very different result.

It's difficult to be too harsh on somebody playing in an unfamiliar role, but this experiment clearly isn't working. And, frankly, it hasn't been for weeks.

Everton Player Ratings

Jordan Pickford — 7/10

Merlin Röhl — 4/10

James Tarkowski — 7.5/10

Jake O'Brien — 7/10

Vitalii Mykolenko — 6/10

James Garner — 7/10

Hayden Hackney — 8.5/10

Tyler Dibling — 6.5/10

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall — 8/10

Tyrique George — 6.5/10

Thierno Barry — 8/10

Substitutes — N/A

Harrison Armstrong, Brennan Johnson, Charly Alcaraz, Ainsley Maitland-Niles and Christian Nørgaard — none made enough of an impact to warrant an individual rating.

What's Next?

Well, would you look at that? We're playing Newcastle again.

Everton travel to St James' Park on Monday evening for a Premier League encounter against the very same opposition, with Moyes hoping his side can finally translate their cup success into some much-needed league momentum.

And with Fleetwood Town awaiting in December's Carabao Cup quarter-finals, there's now a genuine opportunity for Everton to reach the final four of a competition they've never won.

Although, considering Fleetwood have just knocked out Arsenal, perhaps we shouldn't start celebrating that draw quite yet.

After all, this is Everton we're talking about.

James Costello
Everton Club Correspondent at Football Park

An Everton supporter, sports broadcasting enthusiast and self-confessed Formula 1 fanatic, James Costello is a sports journalist with a passion for telling stories that connect supporters with the games they love.

James has built experience across reporting, presenting, commentary and club media, covering everything from Premier League football and Super League rugby to cricket, darts and gymnastics. His work has seen him interview the likes of Sir James Anderson, Matt Peet, Jodie Cunningham and Dave Chisnall, while also producing match reports, features and digital content for clubs including Avro FC and Widnes Vikings.

Comfortable both behind the camera and in front of it, James has developed a growing portfolio of presenting, live reporting and digital content creation. Whether reporting from the touchline, interviewing athletes, producing social media content or hosting on camera, his ambition is simple: to tell engaging stories that bring supporters closer to the sport.

Away from work, James is usually following Everton across the country, keeping up with Formula 1, or finding another excuse to talk about Sonic the Hedgehog.

View all articles by James Costello →