Hull City 2-2 Everton: Match Report and Player Ratings
Everton's unbeaten start to the Premier League season continued on Sunday afternoon following a 2-2 draw with Hull at the MKM Stadium, but the result doesn’t paint the full picture.
The Toffees will be disappointed that they could not hold on to their 2-1 lead, after goals from Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Thierno Barry had overturned Joe Gelhardt's opener, putting the Blues in a promising position to secure another three points.
However, Mohamed Belloumi had other ideas, equalising just six minutes later to ensure Everton's trip to East Yorkshire ended in disappointment. It's now six Premier League matches without defeat, Everton's longest unbeaten start to a campaign since 2013/14. With only Brentford and Manchester City also remaining undefeated, it's certainly something worth celebrating, although I can't help but feel, like many other Evertonians, that this was two points dropped rather than one gained.
And then there were three....
Brentford, Everton and Man City are the only unbeaten teams left in the Premier League this season!
Who will be(e) the last team standing? 🐝 https://t.co/aDP8go9Lel
— Hive (@BrentfordHive) October 11, 2026
A Disrupted Defence
Everton unfortunately couldn’t survive the two-week international break unscathed, as left-back Vitalii Mykolenko picked up a knock whilst away with Ukraine, forcing David Moyes to reshuffle the back four.
Jarrad Branthwaite was shifted across to left-back, with Michael Keane returning to the starting XI alongside James Tarkowski in central defence. It meant breaking up a familiar partnership at the heart of Everton's back four, something that would become increasingly relevant as the afternoon progressed.
Despite those changes, Everton made a promising start and thought they had broken the deadlock when Brennan Johnson bundled the ball home after Hull goalkeeper Konstantinos Tzolakis failed to gather a cross from Branthwaite.
Unfortunately for the Blues, VAR intervened, with referee Michael Salisbury ruling the goal out for offside, something that seems to be a theme for Everton so far this season…
https://t.co/g56SJX0tu8
— Mark Smith (@FPL_Smithy) October 12, 2026
Hull had opportunities of their own, with Tarkowski producing an important intervention to deny Gelhardt shortly before the break. At the other end, Barry headed over from close range following a dangerous Jack Grealish delivery, an opportunity that would unfortunately prove to be a sign of things to come for the Frenchman.
A Second Half That Had It All
The second half burst into life almost immediately, although not in the way Everton would have hoped.
Ainsley Maitland-Niles failed to deal with a ball into Everton's defensive third, allowing Sorba Thomas to release Gelhardt, who lifted his effort beyond Jordan Pickford to give the hosts the lead in the 48th minute.
It was a disappointing way to end a run of three clean sheets in all competitions, particularly considering Everton had looked the more threatening side for much of the contest.
However, Maitland-Niles wasted little time making amends, delivering an excellent cross into the penalty area for Dewsbury-Hall to head home just seven minutes later.
The equaliser appeared to give Everton the momentum they needed, although Barry was doing his best to test the patience of the travelling supporters. The striker somehow failed to convert from almost underneath the crossbar after Branthwaite fired the ball across the face of goal, leaving the Blues wondering whether it was going to be one of those afternoons (again).
Thankfully, the Frenchman eventually remembered where the goal was.
In the 68th minute, Dewsbury-Hall pounced on a loose pass from Thomas before releasing Barry through on goal. This time, the striker made no mistake, firing beyond Tzolakis to complete the comeback and give Everton a deserved lead.
It was Barry's sixth goal of the season so far, continuing an encouraging start to the season for the striker, even if his finishing throughout the afternoon had left plenty to be desired.
Thierno Barry makes no mistake in putting Everton in front for the first time this afternoon! 💥 https://t.co/bBOiRnWabr
— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) October 11, 2026
At that point, you'd have fancied Moyes' side to see the game out. They'd recovered from a disappointing start to the second half, turned the contest around and appeared to have Hull exactly where they wanted them.
Unfortunately, Everton did what they do best, disappointing us.
Just six minutes later, substitute Elliot Stroud found Belloumi inside the penalty area, with the Algerian producing a low finish beyond Pickford to bring Hull level once again.
Having worked so hard to take the lead, conceding in that manner was particularly frustrating. Everton had been given an opportunity to take control of the contest, only to undo much of their good work with another avoidable defensive mistake.
And while Maitland-Niles' individual errors were certainly costly, it's worth considering the impact of Everton's reshuffled back four. With Branthwaite operating out of his usual position and Keane returning to the heart of defence, the Blues lacked some of the familiarity that has made them so difficult to break down this season.
Mykolenko was certainly missed, with Everton's reshuffled defence looking far less convincing than we've become accustomed to this season. And if the Blues struggled to contain Hull's attacking threat, you have to wonder how they'll fare against tougher opposition, particularly with Chelsea up next.
Two Points Dropped?
David Moyes certainly seemed to think so.
The Everton manager admitted that very few of his players had performed to the standards he expected, expressing his frustration at the defensive lapses that allowed Hull back into the contest.
Still, six games unbeaten is nothing to turn your nose up at, particularly given where Everton have found themselves in recent seasons. There are genuine reasons to be encouraged by Moyes' side, even if the performance left plenty of room for improvement.
But if Everton want to establish themselves further up the Premier League table, these are the sorts of matches they need to start winning.
Man of the Match: Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
Dewsbury-Hall was involved in both Everton goals, first finding himself in the right place to head home Maitland-Niles' cross before showing excellent anticipation to intercept Thomas' loose pass and release Barry for the second.
In a match where several Everton players struggled to get going, the midfielder provided the quality needed to turn the contest around. He continues to demonstrate why he's become such an important part of Moyes' side, although he'll undoubtedly be disappointed that his contributions weren't enough to secure all three points.
I've given Dewsbury-Hall a fair bit of stick in previous reports this season, largely because we became so accustomed to performances like this from him last campaign. Hopefully, this is a sign that he's rediscovering that form, because Everton are undoubtedly a better side when he's playing like this.
Drewsberry Hall best player to visit the MKM in years
EFC #hcafc— Will🇬🇧 (@Hcafcwill13) October 11, 2026
Bad Day: Ainsley Maitland-Niles
The defender was at fault for Hull's opener after failing to control the ball before another mistake contributed to Belloumi's equaliser. And when you consider Everton had worked their way back from a goal down to take the lead, the latter was particularly costly.
To his credit, Maitland-Niles did provide an excellent assist for Dewsbury-Hall's equaliser, demonstrating that his afternoon wasn't entirely disastrous. But unfortunately, when you're involved in both goals your side concedes, it's difficult to look beyond the mistakes.
Everton Player Ratings
Jordan Pickford — 5/10: Made a couple of decent saves but was ultimately beaten twice in the second half. Managed to get a hand to Belloumi's equaliser, although couldn't quite keep it out. I’m sure avid Pickford hate watchers will be milking that content for weeks.
Ainsley Maitland-Niles — 4/10: An excellent assist for Dewsbury-Hall, but two costly defensive mistakes overshadowed his contribution.
James Tarkowski — 5/10: A night-and-day difference without Branthwaite alongside him, with Everton looking far less secure defensively than usual. At least I'm glad I never put him in my FPL team.
Michael Keane — 5/10: Not Branthwaite but not Keano’s fault. Did a job but you could tell things didn’t look as secure.
Jarrad Branthwaite — 6/10: Didn't offer quite enough going forward to make up for what Everton lost by moving him out of central defence. Hardly his fault, mind. Shocking trim though.
James Garner — 6/10: A fairly vanilla performance from Jimmy Garner, who struggled to impose himself on the contest. Not necessarily poor, just not particularly memorable either.
Harrison Armstrong — 7/10: So encouraging once again from the youngster. He looked confident and played some really nice balls, shame those getting on the end of it aren’t half as good.
Brennan Johnson — 6/10: Should have had his first Premier League goal for the Toffees, but I’m sure it’ll come.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall — 8/10: Everton's best player on the afternoon. A well-taken equaliser followed by an excellent assist for Barry's goal. His contributions deserved better than a draw.
Jack Grealish — 6/10: Showed glimpses of his quality, including a dangerous delivery for Barry in the first half, but struggled to consistently influence proceedings.
Thierno Barry — 7/10: Where do you start? Missed several promising opportunities before finally finding the net with a composed finish. His sixth goal of the season was a positive, although he'll know he could have had more. Still, hadn’t scored at all this time last year for us.
Substitutes
Tyrique George — 6/10: Really unlucky not to start I felt, but didn’t make the impact we might have thought.
Hayden Hackney — N/A Jake O'Brien — N/A Tyler Dibling — N/A Charly Alcaraz — N/A
What's Next?
Everton return to the Hill Dickinson Stadium on Saturday, 17 October, when Chelsea make the trip to Merseyside, whilst Hull travel to Craven Cottage to take on bottom of the table Fulham.
It feels like a much better performance is needed on Saturday if Everton want to keep the unbeaten streak going, especially with Chelsea’s attacking threat.
At least we’re well on our way to becoming the second Premier League team ever to go unbeaten, shame we’ll still finish 13th.
well at least we're still unbeaten everton gonna be the first team to have an invincible season and finish 13th
— Harry (@Owens_EFC) October 11, 2026
Louis Wheeldon