Newcastle 0-1 Everton Match Report and Player Ratings
Toffees Triumph Over Terrible Toon
Everton edge out a close and hostile encounter against Newcastle at St. James’ Park on Monday night to win their first Premier League game since September and their second victory over the Magpies in 5 days.
The first time was so nice, we had to do it twice. ✌️🔵 https://t.co/H46ZrJOHVm
— Everton (@Everton) November 2, 2026
Not a bad week eh Toffees?
It was a dominant and professional performance from David Moyes' men, who, thanks to Thierno Barry's tap-in early in the second half, took all three points back to Merseyside, leaving Newcastle with only one win at home in the league so far.
Grealish Groans
The talk of the pre-match build-up once again surrounded Jack Grealish, who was absent for the second consecutive game following his disciplinary omission against Newcastle in the Carabao Cup.
Everton cited a lack of match fitness for his continued absence, leaving Moyes to reshuffle his attacking options once again.
Grealish didn't travel with the squad, prompting a second start in a week for Tyrique George, while Merlin Röhl advanced into midfield and Jake O'Brien returned to right-back, thank goodness.
Jarrad Branthwaite returned to the starting XI after concerns before the cup game in midweek as did Harrison Armstrong, replacing the in-form and man of the match performer Hayden Hackney, because a goal and an assist clearly isn’t good enough to start for Everton these days.
Regardless, it was an impressive display from the Toffees in the first half who saw plenty of the ball and had pinned Newcastle down to defending for a large majority of the half, yet the lack of quality in the final third seemed to be haunting the Toffees, even if Halloween had come and gone.
Barry had a golden chance to put the visitors in front as a free-kick bobbled to him in the box, but he thought he would rather attempt to hit William Osula than the ball itself.
A sort of thing we've come to expect from the striker so far this season...
The best chance came just before the break, as Armstrong was played in by Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall inside the box, but the midfielder scuffed his shot from 15 yards out and we were left to rue another half of missed chances, the story of the season so far.
Barry's Back at It
Newcastle rarely threatened, much to the frustration of the home fans, with boos ringing out at the break. Those boos grew exponentially at the beginning of the second half, as Everton found themselves in front.
A quickly taken free-kick caught Newcastle napping, with Garner eventually releasing George down the left. The winger fired a low effort towards goal, which somehow squirmed underneath Lukáš Horníček, and who was there to slot the ball home from 2 yards?
That man Barry again, of course.
My cat could have poked the ball home from that range, but a goal is a goal. Even VAR couldn't find a reason to spoil the celebrations, and Barry was finally able to enjoy his moment.
A second winner for Barry at St. James' Park. 🤌 https://t.co/pG4W9PZnkL
— Everton (@Everton) November 3, 2026
Just, less of these dances Thierno… please?
Contrary to what Everton fans have been accustomed to recently after scoring, the Toffees were eager to put the game beyond any doubt, continuing on the front foot as the Magpies struggled to orchestrate anything spectacular.
O’Brien’s header from close-range forced a good save from Horníček, which was the best chance to double Everton’s lead.
Toffees Stand Tall
Newcastle finally decided to wake up and came tantalisingly close to equalising, as Anthony Elanga's close-range effort struck the post and spun across the goal-line before James Tarkowski somehow scrambled it clear.
The mission was simple from that point onwards for Everton, defend and be as resolute as possible, which the Blues did magnificently. Pickford was rarely troubled, with the best chance falling to Yoane Wissa in the 90th minute, who on the swivel inside the box forced a shot which Pickford saved with his feet.
Not quite the spectacular save from last season against Sandro Tonali, but I’m sure Pickford will be happy with that performance against a team he loves playing against.
Late drama saw Newcastle’s Jacob Ramsey sent off for two yellow cards in as many minutes in stoppage time, which summed up how dismal the home team’s night was.
The game finished 1-0 to the Toffees, marking their third consecutive victory at St. James’ Park. Seems to be a happy hunting ground doesn’t it?
More importantly, it’s a clean sheet and a very strong performance from all of the men in blue, a much-needed three points and a first league away win since the 3-2 victory against the Toon in February.
Best performance of the season, for me.
Well done Mr Moyes and the players.
UTFT.
— Tactically Matt (@TacticallyMatt) November 2, 2026
Man of the Match: Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
Wow, oh wow.
Dewsbury-Hall was back to his best tonight. An avid reader will know just how critical I have been of the midfielder’s lacking performances so far this season, but it all just clicked inside those 90 minutes.
When KDH is good, Everton are good, it’s a simple equation.
He ran the midfield, was brilliant in attack and defence, and it felt like anything good came from him or had him involved in some way.
Despite no goal contributions, I would argue it was his strongest performance without one so far for the club.
Ambition and determination. 👊
KDH on his desire to make a mark for the Toffees. 💙
— Everton (@Everton) November 3, 2026
Now he needs to crack on, because boy have we missed this type of player in this team.
And with Dewsbury-Hall finally rediscovering his best form, there's even less reason for Moyes to rush Grealish back into the starting XI.
Bad Day at the Office — Nobody!
Well, there's a first.
After weeks of finding somebody to criticise, I genuinely struggled to pick out an Everton player who deserved the dreaded Bad Day award.
There were a few missed chances, granted, but this was a collective performance built on discipline, determination and some excellent defending.
Enjoy it while it lasts, lads. I'm sure somebody will give me something to moan about on Friday.
Player Ratings:
Jordan Pickford: 7.5
Jake O’Brien: 7.5
James Tarkowski: 8
Jarrad Branthwaite: 8
Vitalii Mykolenko: 8
James Garner: 7.5
Harrison Armstrong: 8
Merlin Röhl: 7.5
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall: 8.5
Tyrique George: 7
Thierno Barry: 7
Substitutes:
Brennan Johnson, Michael Keane, Hayden Hackney: N/A
What’s Next:
Everton are quickly back in action on Friday night, as they host Coventry at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, as Frank Lampard faces his former club for the first time as manager.
Newcastle face Fulham at Craven Cottage on Saturday, and it remains to be seen if Matthias Jaissle will even be in charge of the Magpies by then.
Louis Wheeldon
Harry Pascoe