Simunic vs Ugarte: Who’s Phantom Sending Off Was Worse?

Simunic vs Ugarte: Who’s Phantom Sending Off Was Worse?

Latest news

Simunic vs Ugarte: Who’s Phantom Sending Off Was Worse?

International football has once again pushed aside domestic club football, with an array of crucial FIFA World Cup play-offs getting played over this two-week break.

However, despite some of the shocks and the heartbreaks those games have already produced, those events are not what has taken the headlines over the last 24 hours. Instead, pan your heads to the game at Wembley Stadium in England’s first of two friendlies this international break, a 1-1 draw with Uruguay – but it is what happened on the pitch which caught many spectators' eyes.

Manuel Ugarte was booked twice by referee Sven Jablonski according to ITV coverage, but was never shown a red card, sparking furious reactions from fans and later the seething reactions from Thomas Tuchel and Harry Maguire.

However, last night was not the first time something as ludicrous as this has happened, and in this article, we will discuss the events of both of these phantom dismissals and the truth behind them.


Croatia Cause Controversy at World Cup

Flashback to the 2006 FIFA World Cup in Germany, a tournament known for having a remarkable 373 red and yellow cards dished out, with 20 of which coming in one match between Portugal and the Netherlands.

However, it was in Group F’s finale, a match contested by Croatia and Australia in Stuttgart where Josip Simunic received three yellow cards before eventually being dismissed by English official Graham Poll.

After two matches each, against Brazil and Japan, the Aussies found themselves in a position where avoiding defeat would confirm their spot in the knockout stage, while Croatia would need victory to earn their spot in the last 16.

The match began in regular fashion, with the score standing at 2-1 to Croatia at the hour mark, before things started to get interesting. In the 62nd minute of the game, Simunic received a yellow for a tactical foul in the middle of the pitch; however, it was later found out that Poll marked this yellow on the Australian side due to Simunic’s accent.

This led his decision to give Simunic which was his second yellow card in the 90th minute to spark ferocity amongst the Oceanian nation – thankfully for the Socceroos, Simunic was finally sent off after receiving his third booking in second half stoppage-time, and the 2-2 scoreline meant they qualified at Croatia’s expense.

For Poll, however, it meant he was sent home shortly after the group stage ended despite being tipped to officiate the final. And for football as a whole, that moment is still remembered to this day, with a player receiving three yellow cards in one game so rare to see.


”A bad day at the office” – That’s for Sure

Now we fast forward to Friday evening, in England’s first friendly fixture in preparation for the World Cup they welcomed Uruguay to the iconic Wembley Stadium, and this time it was a familiar face who should have seen a red card but remarkably avoided it.

Manuel Ugarte, who has been with Manchester United since 2024, was shown by broadcaster ITV to have been given two yellow cards. The first of which came in the 70th minute, for a foul on Cole Palmer, however it was later revealed that this booking was actually handed out to Jose Gimenez for dissent in the aftermath – this was not only seen by people watching on from home either though, as spectators and players within the venue also believed Ugarte was shown the yellow.

This then led to what should have been the midfielder’s second booking and red card after Ben White put the hosts in front, but referee Jablonski did not show a red card – with Opta later revealing that the “second” card was his only booking of the fixture although TV coverage claimed the second booking was “rescinded” by the fourth official.

Things were made even worse six minutes after Ugarte's "second" yellow when the midfielder was substituted off as the visitors remained with 11 men on the pitch before they eventually found an equaliser.

This decision sparked debate among pundits after the game as well England boss Tuchel and senior figure Maguire. Tuchel believed the Polish referee certainly had “a bad day at the office,” before Maguire went on to say.

“Not a good performance throughout the match.”

”A player got two yellow cards on the match and did not even get sent off.”

There has been talk of VAR intervening during the World Cup for second yellow cards and even corners, so there is still hope that even if the officials have a poor day at work, decisions such as the one 20 years ago and the bizarre situation last night does not happen again.

Ben Growdon
Content Writer

Ben Growdon - Content Writer at Football Park

Ben has held a keen interest in writing since a very young age, and has eyed up a career in sports journalism since he was 12. Football is a sport close to Ben's heart, and he has great eye for detail when watching the game, with an interest in becoming a match reporter when graduating Southampton Solent University.

Ben has the experience to write a wide range of article types. From features, quotes pieces and match reports, to transfer news and SEO-driven pieces, Ben holds all the tools to write an engaging, informative articles.

Ben holds extensive knowledge of the Premier League and other top European divisions, but is also remarkably confident in writing about the 92, with an article of his getting noticed by Irish company Balls. Ben has been writing for Football Park since March 2025, and on top of writing for VAVEL, he also works in club media for Eastleigh and Winchester City, where he has worked on various different platforms including X and Instagram.

At Solent, Ben has also taken part in multiple soccer nights, which included reporting live from a National League South fixture. Ben has a deep connection for the sport and, with cricket, is keen to work vastly in these areas, covering matches, conducting interviews, or even commentary.

View all articles by Ben Growdon →