When Ilkay Gundogan joined Barcelona last summer, expectations were high that his leadership and experience would help the club regain its footing. Fresh off captaining Manchester City to a historic treble, he was seen as a crucial addition to a Barcelona side in transition. However, his time at the club has been far from smooth.

Despite strong performances, Gundogan finds himself entangled in the financial and tactical challenges plaguing Barcelona, leading to speculation that he might soon return to Manchester City—a move that reflects the deeper issues facing the Catalan giants.

Financial Struggles: The Push to Offload Gundogan

Barcelona's ongoing financial problems have forced the club to consider offloading Gundogan, despite his importance to the team. His high wage and the need to register new signings like Dani Olmo have made him a financial burden.

Tactical Inconsistencies: A Blessing and a Curse

Gundogan’s versatility, while valuable, has exposed Barcelona’s tactical weaknesses. Originally intended to be a creative force, he has often been deployed in a deeper role due to the underperformance of other players, limiting his effectiveness in attack.

Squad Decisions: The Exclusion of Gundogan

Recent squad selections have intensified speculation about Gundogan’s future. In Barcelona’s latest match, young midfielders Marc Bernal and Marc Casado were chosen over Gundogan, who was not even included in the squad. This decision suggests the club may already be planning for life without him.

Xavi’s Praise: Gundogan’s Impact on the Field

Despite these issues, Gundogan has received praise from Xavi for his ability to elevate the team's play. Statistically, he leads the team in key passing metrics, demonstrating his importance when on the field.

Comparison to Frenkie de Jong: Gundogan’s Willingness to Leave

Unlike Frenkie de Jong, who resisted similar pressure to leave in 2022, Gundogan appears more willing to cooperate with Barcelona’s needs. A return to Manchester City is a possibility, especially given Pep Guardiola's interest in bringing him back.

A Reflection of Barcelona’s Broader Challenges

Gundogan’s potential departure reflects the broader financial and tactical challenges facing Barcelona. His exclusion from recent squads in favor of younger, less experienced players highlights the club’s struggles both on and off the pitch.